Renew Forge vs WooCommerce Subscriptions on its own: what each handles for the UK rules
What WooCommerce Subscriptions documents for the UK subscription rules and what Renew Forge Free and Pro add, rule by rule, with sources.
Renew Forge Free helps WooCommerce Subscriptions stores prepare for the UK subscription rules: a compliance check, one-click cancellation with a confirmation email, an evidence journal and a pre-contract summary on product pages. Nothing touches a subscription until WooCommerce Subscriptions is active. In the table, the WooCommerce Subscriptions documentation describes a Cancel button, renewal notifications and a Cancelled Subscription email, and Renew Forge Pro, a separate plugin, adds renewal reminders, cooling-off refunds and a pre-contract acknowledgement at checkout; where the documentation says nothing about a rule, the table says Not documented and gives no opinion.
Rule by rule: what each handles
The UK subscription rules are in Part 4, Chapter 2 of the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 (the DMCC Act). The left-hand column gives the provisions of the Act as passed, in short; the chapter is not in force yet and the draft Regulations may add detail (see the status line at the end of the page). The other columns say what the WooCommerce Subscriptions documentation describes and what Renew Forge Free and Renew Forge Pro say they do.
| What the Act covers | WooCommerce Subscriptions on its own (its documentation) | Renew Forge Free | Renew Forge Pro (a separate plugin) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Before the customer signs up: key information given together, and for an online sign-up an express acknowledgement that the contract obliges the customer to pay. Without the acknowledgement, “the consumer is not bound by the subscription contract” (s. 256, s. 257, Sch. 23). | The terms are set on the product: “Set the terms for the subscription, including price, payment schedule, length, sign-up fee, and trial period (length, sign-up fee, and trial period are all optional).” (creating a subscription product). The general settings guide describes a Place Order button setting: “Sets the label of the Place Order button on the checkout page when the order contains a subscription.” (general settings). A summary of the key information, or a required acknowledgement that the contract obliges the customer to pay: Not documented. | A summary on subscription product pages: price, billing period, renewal, free trial and how to cancel. The subscription summary appears in front of the Add to Cart block of subscription products, and is also available as the Subscription summary block. | Subscription terms at checkout with a required tick box, on the classic checkout and the Checkout block; the text shown and the tick are saved with the order (documentation). |
| Reminders before a renewal: a reminder notice for each renewal payment that relates to the end of a six-month period, and for the renewal payment that follows a free or discounted start, with an additional, earlier reminder where the customer will not become liable for a further renewal payment until after the end of a 12-month period. The Act gives no number of days: the trader states the period at sign-up and the reminder is due “in advance of the last cancellation date which is reasonable” (ss. 258–259, Sch. 23). | The Subscription Notifications guide describes renewal reminder emails: “Subscription Renewal Notification, to remind subscribers about upcoming renewals, whether the payment is automatic or requires manual action.” It also describes a free-trial notification: “Subscription Free Trial Expiration Notification, to inform customers that their free trial period is ending soon.” On timing it says “The latest a reminder can be sent is 1 day before the subscription event.” and “Enter how many days/weeks/months before the subscription event the reminder should be sent.” (Subscription Notifications). An additional, earlier reminder: Not documented. | The Compliance check has a reminders item, and Renew Forge lets a plugin that sends renewal reminders describe them in one line; the compliance check then shows the reminders item as passed. The reminders themselves are in the next column. | Renewal reminders by email before the payments the Act requires a reminder for, with an additional earlier reminder for renewals twelve months or more apart; each reminder is planned once per payment, retried if the email fails, and logged. SMS reminders through your own Twilio or Vonage account, off by default (Store + SMS and Agency plans). Documentation: renewal reminders. |
| Ending online: the customer must be able to end the contract “in a way which is straightforward”, and for a contract entered into online, to end it online (s. 260). | “Active subscriptions display a Cancel button by default on the View Subscription page.” The guide lists the conditions for showing it, among them that “the payment gateway used to purchase the subscription must support subscription cancellation” (suspend, cancel or remove an item). | A cancel button in My account → Subscriptions and on each subscription page, and a cancellation block and shortcode for account pages built with blocks or a page builder. One press cancels. A second press changes nothing. After a cancellation the customer keeps access until the end of the period already paid for and no further payment is taken. By default the WooCommerce Subscriptions Cancel link is replaced by the Renew Forge button, so customers have a single way to cancel; you can keep it in the settings. Documentation: the cancel button and the confirmation email. | None listed. |
| After the customer ends it: an “end of contract notice”, in writing on a durable medium, that states the date the contract was or will be cancelled or came or will come to an end (s. 261). | The Subscription emails guide lists a Cancelled Subscription email: “Sent when a subscription has been canceled by the customer (at the time when they click ‘cancel’) or store manager. Sent to the store manager by default.” It says you can “configure recipients for subscription related emails” (Subscription emails). An email to the customer on cancellation: Not documented. | A confirmation email with the date the subscription ends, sent as soon as the customer cancels. Cancellations made another way (with the WooCommerce Subscriptions Cancel link, by a shop manager in wp-admin, by a payment gateway or through the REST API) are confirmed and journaled too, once per cancellation. A confirmation email that failed is tried again three more times within 24 hours. | None listed. |
| Cooling-off: a 14-day initial cooling-off period, and a 14-day renewal cooling-off period, with a cooling-off notice for each renewal cooling-off period. A renewal cooling-off period begins on the day of a relevant renewal, not of every renewal: for example the renewal payment that follows a free or discounted start (s. 265(3)). The right is “exercisable in any circumstances”; how much is refunded is left to regulations (s. 264, s. 265, s. 266, s. 267). | Not documented. The WooCommerce Subscriptions pages we read do not describe cooling-off periods, a cooling-off notice or refunds for cancelling in one. | None listed. | Cancel and refund in My account during a cooling-off period: the unused share of the subscription’s payments (or, for goods, the whole payment when the goods come back) refunded through the payment gateway where it supports refunds, or listed for the shop to refund by hand with a due date. Cooling-off notice by email at the start of each renewal cooling-off period. Documentation: cooling-off and refunds. |
| Showing what happened: in a dispute about whether the trader gave information or a notice, “The burden of proof lies with the trader” (s. 272(6)); in a dispute about whether, and when, the consumer notified the trader that they are ending or cancelling, the burden lies with the consumer (s. 272(7)). | Not documented. The WooCommerce Subscriptions pages we read do not describe a record of the notices sent and the cancellations received, kept as evidence. They do say that related orders are linked to a subscription “so the subscription can have a record of its past transactions” (Subscription Orders), and, of the subscription notes shown for an early renewal, “These notes record the process of creating an early renewal order, processing the order, and either the successful renewal or errors associated with the renewal.” (Early Renewal Guide). | An evidence journal of every cancellation: who, when, from which screen and whether the confirmation email was sent, with a CSV export of the journal, exactly as stored (documentation). | Evidence export of the journal and the reminder log for a period, as CSV or JSON. Retention: evidence older than the period you choose (six years by default) is deleted once a day, and each deletion is recorded. Dispute dossier for one subscription, built from the evidence journal, the reminder log, the order records and the WooCommerce orders: terms shown and accepted at purchase, reminders, cancellation and cooling-off, and refunds, each with the time it was recorded, as a printable page or a JSON file. |
Outside the rules above, Renew Forge Free adds a compliance check with 14 items about your store, each with its status, what we found, what to do and the provision it is about (documentation).
How they fit together
Renewal reminders, cooling-off refunds and a pre-contract acknowledgement at checkout are part of Renew Forge Pro, a separate plugin. In Renew Forge the wording and timings are settings you can change, because the regulations are not yet made. For what the Act says and what is still open, see the guide to the UK subscription rules.
How this comparison was made
Statements about WooCommerce Subscriptions are quotations from the woocommerce.com documentation pages listed under Sources, read on 30 October 2026. Where those pages say nothing about a rule, the table says Not documented and gives no opinion: that means we did not find it in the pages we read, not that a store cannot do it some other way. None of the pages we read mentions the DMCC Act. We did not read the documentation of WooCommerce core or of add-ons, and we did not test WooCommerce Subscriptions on a store.
Statements about Renew Forge are word for word from the promises in the readme files of Renew Forge Free and Renew Forge Pro. None listed means a readme makes no promise for that rule.
Sources
All read on 30 October 2026. Quotations from legislation.gov.uk and GOV.UK are Crown copyright, reproduced under the Open Government Licence v3.0.
- WooCommerce Subscriptions documentation, quoted above: Creating a Subscription Product; Subscriptions General Settings; Subscription Notifications; Suspend, Cancel, or Remove an Item; Subscription emails; Subscription Orders; Early Renewal Guide
- WooCommerce Subscriptions documentation, also read: Subscriber’s View; Subscription Renewal Process; Subscriptions Status Guide; Subscriptions FAQ
- Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, Part 4, Chapter 2 (subscription contracts); the sections and the schedule are linked where they are cited above
- GOV.UK press release, 9 August 2026: PM starts roll out of ‘everyday fixes’ on the cost of living – ending rip-off discounts and subscription traps
- The Consumer Subscription Contracts (Cancellation and Information) Regulations 2026 (draft), regulation 1; Parliament procedure browser, work package for the draft Regulations
Status as of 30 October 2026: the rules are announced for January 2027 (GOV.UK, 9 August 2026: “New rules will now come into force in January 2027, in time for when customers often start new subscriptions for the year ahead.”). The draft Regulations name 1 January 2027 (regulation 1(2): “These Regulations come into force on 1st January 2027.”). They were laid before Parliament in October 2026 (Parliament procedure browser). The page on legislation.gov.uk says “This is a draft item of legislation and has not yet been made as a UK Statutory Instrument.”, so they are a draft, not yet made, and the wording may still change.
Updated 30 October 2026
A tool, not legal advice.
Try Renew Forge Free on your own store: Renew Forge on WordPress.org